Toward Ethical Eating

esxaton-Farm_Cows__Factory_Cows_by_mfreiheit"Are you vegetarian for health reasons or ethical reasons?"

Unfortunately, this question is often posed after someone has invited me over for dinner and has grilled up a sirloin steak just for me, because I failed to tell them that I don't eat meat anymore. (Sorry, friends! You know who you are). I'm getting better, though. Just the other day, my sister invited the family over after church for a barbeque. When I reminded her that I don't do meat, she considerately bought a package of tofurkey sausage. I'm so special and such a pain of a dinner guest these days.

A little social awkwardness is worth it, however, because my answer to the question is the latter: I am a vegetarian for ethical reasons.

But I'm no St. Francis of Assisi (the patron saint of the environment and animal welfare), because, for one thing, I don't believe that eating meat per se is wrong. Furthermore, I'm pescetarian, which means I eat seafood. For purists, that's just a subcategory of carnivore.

So if I don't think that eating meat is bad, and I in fact eat "meat from the sea," in what way is my annoying new diet ethically based?

The decision to go meatless was and is entirely based on the horrible truth of factory farming. An intensive approach to mass-produce meat, milk, and eggs at the lowest cost, factory farming is hell on earth for cows, pigs, chickens, and other animals. There are probably factory farms that have better records than others regarding animal care; but as a whole, this kind of farming, which has all but replaced family farming, has had disastrous consequences for animals.

Space won't allow me to paint the picture, and that has already been done convincingly by others, even within the pages of PRISM. So as to why I've removed meat from my diet, I resonate with the simple response offered by the musician Moby, who states, "I love animals, and I don't want to be a part of anything that…contributes to their suffering."

It would be a gross understatement to say that factory-farmed animals suffer; the treatment they endure is both savage and severe. In order to mass-produce meat, milk, and eggs for an increasingly demanding public, factory-farmed animals are subject to excruciating procedures including branding, clipping, de-teething, and castration (all without benefit of anesthesia, of course). They are also subjected to overbreeding, unnatural diets and medicine, and deprivation of sunlight. And all of this is before they're mass slaughtered by less-than-precise methods.

What really gives me nightmares, however, is how many of these animals are confined to spaces just slightly bigger than themselves for most, if not all, of their lives. For example, breeding pigs, by far the most intelligent of farm animals, are placed in gestation crates, a space so small that they cannot even turn around, for the duration of their pregnancy (four months). After they give birth to piglets, they are transferred to farrowing crates, which are no bigger than the gestation crates, until the piglets are weaned—at which time they are impregnated again and placed back into gestation crates. This process continues until they go to the slaughterhouse. Many develop diseases from having to sleep in their own feces and sores from lying down all day.

Not  surprisingly, many also display symptoms of madness. They endure this suffering so we can eat bacon for breakfast and pork chops for dinner.

And what about calves prepared for veal? Not only are they placed in extremely small crates, their heads are often tethered by a short chain, essentially immobilizing them except to move toward their food bowl located in front of them. They are in this tortured state for several months before being slaughtered. This, so we can enjoy tender beef called veal. The truth is, factory-farmed animals never get to live before they're killed.

I don't want any part of that! It is an affront to my sense of human decency, and it violates my understanding of the compassion and justice of God.

It is animal cruelty, not eating meat, that is evil. Although a strong biblical case for vegetarianism can be made, I don't believe the Bible ultimate prohibits eating meat. For example, Peter's vision in Acts 10 had Jesus saying, "kill and eat" from a spread of animals that Jewish law forbade (v. 13). Of course, read in the context of the passage, Jesus simply used "unclean animals" as an object lesson to convey to Peter the great truth of Gentile inclusion in the plan of God. But eating meat was certainly not frowned upon here. And did not Jesus' miraculous feeding of the 5,000 begin with five loaves and two fish? Evidently, Jesus felt fine about serving fish and bread to the hungry masses.

So in essence, if animals get a chance to live before we "kill and eat" them, I don't have an ethical problem with it. Hunting and fishing for food are different from factory farming.

I've only just begun to align my eating with my ethics. But it is a beginning. For two years running now, my pescetarian diet has been but a part of the journey toward living according to God's shalom, which includes just relationships with creation and its creatures. I'm not all the way there yet, but the trajectory feels very right.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

You May Also Want to Read

Comment policy: ESA represents a wide variety of understandings and practices surrounding our shared Christian faith. The purpose of the ESA blog is to facilitate loving conversation; please know that individual authors do not speak for ESA as a whole. Even if you don\'t see yourself or your experience reflected in something you read here, we invite you to experience it anyway, and see if God can meet you there. What can take away from considering this point of view? What might you add? The comments section below is where you can share the answers to those questions, if you feel so moved. Please express your thoughts in ways that are constructive, purposeful, and respectful. Give those you disagree with the benefit of the doubt, and assume they are neither idiots nor evil. Name-calling, sweeping condemnations, and any other comments that suggest you have forgotten that we are all children of God will be deleted. Thank you!

3 Responses

  1. Irma says:

    I guess my question to you is why not buy your meat from family run farms and fresh food markets? Why throw the baby out with the bath Water? I am sure you can find stores and markets that sell only farm grown meats and vegetables even in a city. We live just outside of Buffalo and we have access to all kinds of farm fresh veggies, free range eggs, fruits,chickens,etc. So honestly, I don't get it.

    • Sarah King says:

      This is Sarah. I won't speak for Al, but I can answer for myself. We do try to support our local farmers via participation in CSAs and local food co-ops (we purchase vegetables and fruit). But "local" or "family run" doesn't mean humane. And even if an animal has a lovely life that honors his or her God-created cow-ness or chicken-ness…there's still the brutal and unnecessary slaughter at the end. Animals labeled "organic" or "free range" usually end up at the same filthy and fast-moving slaughterhouses as those who are conventionally raised.

    • Sarah King says:

      It's great that you can do that! And I imagine you eat less meat than the typical American as a result of having access to farms in your area. The current situation with factory farming (which produces the vast majority of animal products now) is that the demand for animal products is simply too high to meet without industrialization. — swk

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.