Jesus' Surprising Interactions With Other Religions

Photo by suc /

By Jim Baton

Ding-dong. As I head for the door, my daughter screams. "Dad! Do not open that door!"

I turn to find my daughter peeking out the window. "Why not?" I ask.

"It's those people again. You know, the ties, the bikes…why do they have to bother us?"

Think about the last interaction you had with someone from a different religion—maybe the Jehovah's Witness that knocked on your door, the Muslim woman watching her kids play at the park, or the New Ager who tried to sell you healing crystals. Did you approach the interaction with any particular goal in mind? Were you successful in meeting that goal, or not?

Think about the last interaction you had with someone from a different religion. Did you approach the interaction with any particular goal in mind? Were you successful in meeting that goal, or not?

I can recall many instances in my life when I worked up the courage to talk to someone from another religion, with the goal of helping them see the Truth. More often than not, the conversation ended with me failing at my goal and very little chance that either of us would want to meet again.

Jesus didn't leave that kind of bad taste in people's mouths, probably because he approached those of other religions very differently than we do.

Though most of Jesus' ministry occurred in a small region of the world to a largely homogenous Jewish society, he still found opportunities to interact with those of foreign backgrounds, who probably carried either partially or fully their traditional religions with them. Jesus spoke with Romans, who came from a polytheistic background; with Syrians and Canaanites, traditionally worshippers of idols including Baal and Ashtoreth; and with Samaritans, whose religion was similar to the Jews in that they followed the Torah and believed in a coming Messiah, but had differences in how they worshiped and looked to Mount Gerizim as their holiest site. (The Samaritan religion is still around today.)

The Gospels record Jesus' interactions with specific foreigners such as the Roman Centurion with a sick servant (Luke 7); the Roman governor Pilate (John 18-19); the Canaanite woman with a sick daughter (Matthew 15); the Samaritan leper grateful for his healing (Luke 17); the sinful Samaritan woman at the well (John 4); the allegorical Good Samaritan (Luke 10); and many unnamed sick and demonized from the regions of Syria and the Decapolis who were most likely not Jewish (Matthew 4 & 8; Mark 3 & 7). In all these interactions we find Jesus' approach to be surprisingly different from how he approached the Pharisees or his own disciples.

Surely Jesus would desire that all of these foreigners leave their false religions and embrace the truth. So how did he approach them? Reading each of the passages mentioned above would be highly instructional for those of us who claim to follow Jesus. Here's my summary of how Jesus interacted with those of other religions:

What Jesus DID:

– healed the sick
– delivered the demonically oppressed
– told people to tell others what God had done for them
– praised people for their great faith
– praised people as examples of what God wants
– announced they would feast in heaven with the earlier prophets.

Only when he was asked did Jesus reveal himself as Messiah (John 4) and King (John 18).

What Jesus DIDN'T do:

– follow his own Jewish culture's prejudicial norms
– condemn or rebuke
– warn of judgment or hell
– argue theology, debate, quote the Scriptures, ask if people wanted to know the Gospel, or ask people to change

Think about that for a moment. Jesus didn't try to convince people to believe anything new, change any behavior, or join his group. He simply loved them, praised the good in them, and only answered the questions they were actually asking.

A survey conducted in January 2017 by the Pew Research Center provides insight into how Americans currently feel about different religious groups. Two results from this survey are particularly apropos:

1. The young generation (age 18-29) feel more warmly toward Buddhists (+66), Hindus and Catholics (+64), and Jews (+62) than they do toward Evangelical Christians (+59). Evangelical Christians in fact rank closer to Atheists (+59) and Muslims (+58).

2. Although Republicans have the warmest feelings for Evangelical Christians (+71), Democrats put Evangelical Christians near the bottom of the list with Mormons (+53 & +52 respectively), far behind Jews (+66), Catholics and Buddhists (+64), Hindus (+61), Atheists (+57) and even Muslims (+56).

The study also found that Americans tend to feel most warmly toward those who are like themselves. No wonder Republicans and the elderly like evangelicals—they're showing a preference for their own group. But for the many out there who do NOT identify as evangelicals—whether they're from the young generation, the Democratic Party, or another religious group—their feelings toward evangelicals are not so warm. In fact, according to author Joseph Mattera, many American Muslims "believe Christians hate them."

How can we change this negative perception? By changing the dynamics of our interactions. We need to leave behind some of the agenda-based dialogue and argumentative approaches that have neither achieved our goals of convincing others to change nor reflected the heart of our Savior. It's time we got back to doing what Jesus did—loving, healing, praising, and responding to what is truly on people's hearts.

We shouldn't do these things so that people from other backgrounds will like us, or even so they will convert—we should do them because we claim to follow Jesus. The more we become like him, the more magnetically people will be drawn to us, and discover for themselves that Jesus is "full of grace and truth" (John 1:14).

Jim Baton's 20 years living in a Muslim nation have birthed a series of novels that are transforming people's perceptions on Muslims and how God would have us relate to them in love. His most recent novel, A Violent Light, was released in December 2016.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

You May Also Want to Read

  • By Elli Atchison and Molly Lorden “When the righteous cry out the Lord hears them and delivers them from all…

  • By Elli Atchison and Molly Lorden “Love God with all your heart, soul, mind and strength. And then, love your…

Comment policy: ESA represents a wide variety of understandings and practices surrounding our shared Christian faith. The purpose of the ESA blog is to facilitate loving conversation; please know that individual authors do not speak for ESA as a whole. Even if you don\'t see yourself or your experience reflected in something you read here, we invite you to experience it anyway, and see if God can meet you there. What can take away from considering this point of view? What might you add? The comments section below is where you can share the answers to those questions, if you feel so moved. Please express your thoughts in ways that are constructive, purposeful, and respectful. Give those you disagree with the benefit of the doubt, and assume they are neither idiots nor evil. Name-calling, sweeping condemnations, and any other comments that suggest you have forgotten that we are all children of God will be deleted. Thank you!

6 Responses

  1. Edward says:

    Nice to read but the author missed Jesus' point completely! Jesus presented Himself as the light of the world and bread of life and more! That was a wake up call to all human beings to follow Him and leave all other religions!

    • Jose A. Garcia Schmidt says:

      You're absolutely correct. Also, the author of this article states that:

      What Jesus DIDN'T do:

      – follow his own Jewish culture's prejudicial norms (That's because such culture was of the world and Jesus was God in the flesh who came to spread the Gospel).

      – condemn or rebuke. (What??? Jesus rebuked many to warn them of what their sins would lead to).

      – warn of judgment or hell (Jeus preached about hell and judgement more than ANYTHING else and a rudimentary reading of the Bible would show this).

      This "author" has been living in Muslim countries for too long.

  2. Maktesh says:

    Jim Baton states that these are things Jesus didn't do:
    1. Condemn or rebuke
    2. Warn of judgment or hell
    3. Argue theology, debate, quote the Scriptures, ask if people wanted to know the Gospel, or ask people to change anything.

    Jesus actually did all of these things. A lot. Perhaps the author's argument is that He didn't interact this way with people of other faiths, but that would also be inaccurate (and there are far too few recorded cases to solidify that stance). Many of the crowds Jesus taught were filled with "non-Jews."

    I appreciate Baton's heart for not alienating unbelievers or placing a stumbling block in their path, but I think this approach takes it a little too far.

  3. Allen says:

    What Bible are you reading, friend? Israelites were told to Kill anyone who would take them away from 100% trust in Yahweh…the father of our Messiah. Also, he preached ALOT of outer darkness to those who would play with Universalism concerning his Father's way, without repentance. Leave religion and study God's word!

  4. Tim Moreland says:

    "Jesus didn't try to convince people to believe anything new, change any behavior, or join his group."
    There are myriad examples in the Gospels of Jesus doing all three of these things.
    And the woman at the well never asked Jesus if he was the Messiah.
    Jesus praised Gentiles when they expressed faith in Him not faith in their false religions.
    And Jesus said (Luke 24) "Thus it is written, that the Christ would suffer and rise again from the dead the third day, and that repentance for forgiveness of sins would be proclaimed in His name to all the nations…"

  5. chris dorf says:

    What are you afraid of? Helping and loving someone who you say is from a false religion and God will burn you in Hell for it? People have the primacy of conscience, and if they believe that the religion that they learned as a child was true according to conscience, that is the guide they have. That Jesus said that He is the gate to the sheepfold is NOT debated…that there is a final judgement for ALL people is also NOT debated.

    "Document on Human Fraternity for world peace and living together:
    Faith leads a believer to see in the other a brother or sister to be supported and loved. Through faith in God, who has created the universe, creatures and all human beings (equal on account of his mercy), believers are called to express this human fraternity by safeguarding creation and the entire universe and supporting all persons, especially the poorest and those most in need.

    This transcendental value served as the starting point for several meetings characterized by a friendly and fraternal atmosphere where we shared the joys, sorrows and problems of our contemporary world. We did this by considering scientific and technical progress, therapeutic achievements, the digital era, the mass media and communications. We reflected also on the level of poverty, conflict and suffering of so many brothers and sisters in different parts of the world as a consequence of the arms race, social injustice, corruption, inequality, moral decline, terrorism, discrimination, extremism and many other causes.

    From our fraternal and open discussions, and from the meeting that expressed profound hope in a bright future for all human beings, the idea of this Document on Human Fraternity was conceived. It is a text that has been given honest and serious thought so as to be a joint declaration of good and heartfelt aspirations. It is a document that invites all persons who have faith in God and faith in human fraternity to unite and work together so that it may serve as a guide for future generations to advance a culture of mutual respect in the awareness of the great divine grace that makes all human beings brothers and sisters."

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.